Misconceptions Owners Have About Renting Their Home

December 5, 2022

Thinking about renting your home but worried it will be more work than it’s worth? If you’re contemplating handling everything yourself, it might be. You may be working full time and have other life obligations that make becoming a landlord feel unmanageable. However, there are some common misconceptions about rental properties, and a property management company can be really beneficial. Read on to find out more.

Misconception #1: Finding Good Tenants is Hard

If you decide to become a landlord, you have to figure out ways to advertise your home to potential renters. While you might get lucky and find someone through a friend, there’s a good chance you’ll have to invest time and possibly money in reaching a broader network of people. Also, you’ll have to spend time showing your home and evaluating applicants. 


However, if you work with a property management company, we’ll take care of this for you. We list your home for rent through our extensive local networks, various online platforms, and advertise it effectively. In addition, we meet potential tenants, provide walk throughs, and thoroughly screen applicants to check their background and credit, and past rental payment history. It’s our job to find the most qualified tenant, and this is a responsibility we take very seriously.

Misconception #2: Determining Rental Rates is Complicated

For those who don’t have experience in real estate, figuring out how much to charge for rent might feel daunting. You don’t want to underestimate the rent and miss out on potential income. On the other hand, you don’t want to overestimate it, leaving your home vacant for an extended period of time. 

Here at Windermere Property Management, our property managers live right here in Kitsap County and know the local market very well. They will help you determine a competitive rental rate using local market data, current market conditions, and the value of your home. In addition, we’re responsible for answering tenant questions and fielding calls – one less thing for you to do.

Misconception #3: Renting Makes Selling a Home Harder

Some homeowners believe that renting their home will make it harder to sell later. This is a common misconception. Preparing your home to rent prompts you to make improvements and minor upgrades that you may have put off. This includes things such as deep cleaning, replacing hardware, purchasing new appliances if necessary, and adding a fresh coat of paint. These efforts will make your home look more attractive to renters and it will be easier to sell later. 

Additionally, renters help call attention to maintenance issues. Addressing these issues consistently maintains your home at the level buyers require, making it ready to sell in the future. Plus, working with a local property management company makes all of this extra easy. We’ll help you identify the most cost effective ways to prepare your home for the rental market. And, we’ll deal with any maintenance issues that arise. We have an extensive list of vetted and experienced contractors. Our electronic work order system streamlines the process so we can resolve issues quickly and keep you in the loop.

Misconception #4: Renters Won’t Take Care of My Home

Many homeowners worry about renting to someone who doesn’t take care of their home. The vast majority of renters take good care of rental homes because they’re living there and for a time, it becomes their home. If you’re not able to properly screen each candidate, it can be harder to find great tenants on your own. We have an extensive screening process to prevent worst case scenarios. By running credit and background checks, checking references, and meeting potential tenants in person, we do this important work for you.

Misconception #5: Renting Isn’t Worth It

Sometimes homeowners feel overwhelmed by the idea of renting out their home and think it’s simply not worth the hassle. If you’re considering handling everything on your own, this can become a reality, especially when it comes to collecting rent, and maintaining long-term tenants. The last thing you want is your house sitting empty while you are still paying the mortgage and other costs. 


By working with a property management company, you don’t have to worry about these things. In fact, we can actually help increase your profits. By using an in-depth screening process to find the best renters and reduce the time your home sits vacant, we make sure your investment property maximizes profits. Additionally, skilled marketing, accounting, collections, and disbursements are handled ethically and efficiently.

Misconception #6: Property Management Companies Lack Customer Service

Homeowners often worry that a property management company won’t provide the customer service needed to properly care for their home. This really comes down to the philosophy of each company. At Windermere, we treat all of the properties we oversee as if they are our own. Each of our property managers works hard to provide the highest level of customer service and protect each homeowner’s investment. As Property Manager Bobbi Neal explains, "Property management allows me to develop a long-standing relationship with my owners. Many have worked with me since the very beginning. Their trust in managing one of their most valuable investments is something I do not take lightly. There is nothing I love more than owners referring me to their friends and family."

Clear, consistent communication is very important to us. We offer a Tenant Portal and an Owners Portal so issues and questions can be addressed quickly and securely. For owners, we provide online on-demand access to your statements, and tenants can pay safely and quickly through our online payment options.


If you're now feeling more confident about renting your home, Windermere Property Management/West Sound is ready to assist you. To get started, contact one of our expert property managers today.


Share this post


You May Also Like to Read

August 19, 2025
Renting out your home often comes with a mix of emotions and expectations. Managing your expectations as the owner and those of your tenants is a crucial part of the rental process. Here are some tips to help you achieve successful outcomes. Understanding the Rental Market Before renting out your home, do your research. Look at your local rental market. Are there a lot of homes for rent in your city? What about in your neighborhood? Do they sit unoccupied or are they rented out quickly? What is the average rental price for a home that is similar to yours? It’s important to set competitive rental prices while understanding supply and demand. If you work with a reputable property management company that has local expertise, they will know the market well and will properly price your rental. Preparing Your Home for Rent Ensure your home is rent-ready by prioritizing safety. As a landlord, you will be required to keep the premises fit for human habitation . This Washington state law encompasses many safety standards and home repair projects. For example, landlords must make sure that carbon monoxide and smoke detectors are in working order, as well as major electrical and plumbing fixtures and appliances. Now is the time to make any necessary repairs and deep clean your property. Whether you are renting your home furnished or unfurnished, everything should be in good condition. Check out our article for tips on preparing your property for rent . Additionally, you may want to consider some budget-friendly upgrades to enhance your home before you rent it out. It can increase the value of your home and attract more attention. Setting Realistic Financial Expectations While an investment property can be financially beneficial, we highly recommend calculating potential rental income and expenses. It’s important to understand the costs of property management and maintenance. Also, you’ll want to prepare for potential vacancies and financial fluctuations. Consider the legal side of rental properties as well. Every landlord should be familiar with local, state, and federal fair housing laws . For instance, Washington has specific laws about how security deposits are assessed, held, and returned to tenants. Increasing the rent or terminating a lease requires adherence to specific guidelines. Therefore, you’ll want to take time to do your research and consider these legal factors when pricing your home for rent . If the legal side of property management or the time required to effectively manage a rental seems overwhelming, you may want to utilize a property management company. While this does come at a cost, it can be beneficial , saving you time and money by offering professional marketing, preventative maintenance, built-in tenant screening, and property managers who are well-versed in landlord-tenant laws. Check out our local experts here at Windermere Property Management . Communication and Relationship Management After screening potential tenants, conducting credit checks, and calling references, it is essential to foster positive landlord-tenant relationships with your new renters. This begins with clear, open communication. Setting expectations with tenants from the start paves the way for transparency and builds trust. Renting out your home requires both project management and relationship management. This means that you are ready to handle sudden, needed repairs, answer contract questions, and deal with unexpected issues in a prompt and professional manner. Long-Term Planning It’s wise to set long-term goals for your rental property from the start. Renting out your home for a couple of years while you’re living elsewhere comes with one set of expectations and requirements, while renting it out as passive income for the next 10+ years is very different. Additionally, if you plan to sell it within the next few years, you will also have certain objectives to meet regarding upkeep and preserving or increasing its market value. Your local rental market may also change, so creating a plan that is both proactive and flexible is the key. If you have any questions, our property managers are here to assist you.
before and after renter homes
July 30, 2025
Renters: Need to update your rental home? Here are some budget-friendly DIY projects, before and after videos, and tips to help you get started.
couple-looking-for-homes-for-rent-screen
June 10, 2025
Looking at homes for rent in Kitsap County, WA? Here are some questions to ask beforehand to ensure it's the rental property for you.
home-decor-Kitsap-ideas
May 5, 2025
Brighten your home with local home decor found here in Kitsap County. These items are less than $100 and perfect for summer.
April 3, 2025
Check out these ways to make your rental property more energy efficient, which can reduce utility bills, help the environment, and enhance your home's value.
March 4, 2025
Rainy days in the Pacific Northwest aren't for everyone, but there are many ways to make them more enjoyable. And, as we head into spring, keep in mind that this darker rainy season is temporary. Soon, we'll have more daylight hours, and spring flowers will be blooming. Check out these ideas for making rainy days as fun as possible. Stay active Whether it’s joining a local gym, starting an at-home gym practice, or going for a walk despite the rain, staying active is essential for your mental and physical health during the rainy season. Also, nature is the Pacific Northwest’s playground. Many local trails have thick forests that provide shelter from the rain and shield you from the worst of it. Invest in proper clothing and gear Similarly, if being outside and staying active is your preferred activity method, don’t let the weather stop you. Investing in proper clothing, shoes, and gear can make almost any day an outside day. Many local stores, like Wildernest on Bainbridge Island and Flicka in Poulsbo, have waterproof jackets and shoes . Invest in a pair of warm wool socks to keep your feet dry. On really cold days, put a pair of warmers into your gloves or shoes. Talk to a doctor about options If you're new to the Pacific Northwest, consider talking to your doctor about other ways to help your body physically adapt to the winter weather and darkness that is unique to this area. They might recommend daily vitamin D supplements and a sun lamp . Sun lamps mimic natural light and can be effective for those with Seasonal Affective Disorder. Speak to your doctor before making any changes. Try boredom busters for kids Do you have kids who are starting to bounce off the walls or are (conversely) staying glued to their devices? Check out this list of fun boredom busters to break up the long days. Even a quick card or board game can put a spark of controlled energy into the room. There are also many local indoor play spaces to choose from in the area. There are play spaces for toddlers , indoor trampoline parks , laser tag venues , and arcades for teens. Lean into seasonal sports Enjoying a winter sport can mean everything from watching it live to watching it on TV to participating in it. Living so close to the Olympic Mountains and Mount Rainier means various options for skiing, snowboarding, tubing, snowshoeing, and more. In addition, for those looking to watch sports live in the winter, Seattle is home to many professional teams, as well as minor league and college teams. If you prefer to stay off the roads and in the comfort of your own home, invite a couple of friends over to watch a game together. Start a new hobby For many, the rainy days provide a little more time since there’s often less running around. You can use that extra time to pick up a new hobby. Perhaps you’d like to get on the sourdough bread bandwagon, pick up woodworking, or learn how to knit. Maybe you’ve never made a mosaic but want to give it a try. Whatever you choose, these slower days provide the perfect opportunity to give it a whirl. BARN (Bainbridge Artisan Resource Network) hosts a range of workshops in an incredible space. Be sure to check them out. Choose an indoor home project to complete Meanwhile, if you feel stuck at home and don’t feel like picking up a new hobby, then why not tidy up your home a bit? Since this is the time of year when you may find yourself at home more, think about doing something that will make it feel more inviting. Purge old clothes, household items, and toys no longer being used. Pick a room to reorganize or rearrange the furniture. Hang up the pictures that you’ve been meaning to get to, or re-paint your home office. Tackling and completing a home improvement project will create a great sense of accomplishment. Take the time to slow down On the other hand, many take rainy days as an opportunity to embrace a slower lifestyle. That could mean spending the day reading a book or finding a new series to binge-watch without feeling guilty. Perhaps you let yourself enjoy a cup of coffee or tea in the morning for a longer amount of time. Or, since it’s dark outside, go to bed earlier or sleep in on the weekends. Some call it wintering and fully accept the conditions of this season while remaining home. Embrace Scandinavian Hygge Concepts Faced with even worse weather challenges in the winter than those in the Pacific Northwest, many Scandinavian countries still top the world happiness charts. How do they do it? Explore the concept of Danish hygge and find ways to embrace it in your own life. Check out this list of 100 Ideas to Add Hygge Into Your Everyday Life . Candles, warm blankets and a favorite mug for hot drinks are just the tip of the iceberg to creating a life of hygge. Plan a future trip Having something to look forward to can help pass the time during long rainy stretches. Think of an activity or trip that you’d like to do in the future and start planning. It could be an overnight trip or your weeklong summer vacation. It can be a camping trip, a day at the spa, or an upcoming concert. If all else fails, plan next year’s vacation to somewhere warm during this time to escape the cold days. It doesn’t matter where you go, or when you go, or for how long. Simply put something on the calendar you’re looking forward to and start making it happen. We know the rainy season isn't for everyone. Keep in mind that longer, sunnier days are on the horizon. In the meantime, take advantage of some of these ideas to make the next few weeks (and future winters) not just bearable but enjoyable.
winter-activities-fun
February 1, 2025
Kitsap County and the surrounding area is home to fun winter activities for kids and adults. Here are some indoor and outdoor ideas.
elevate-rental-property-painting
January 7, 2025
If your rental property needs to be updated, here are 6 ideas that will increase the home's value and attract renters.
home-related-gifts-holidays
By 1917687 December 4, 2024
Shop small for the holidays with these unique, local gift ideas. Kitsap County has many memorable options for everyone on your list.
smart-home-technology
November 19, 2024
Smart home technology can be beneficial for your rental property. Find out which devices could benefit you and your tenants.
Show More